(11) Narrow streets with people walking in the road

Tokyo is incredibly pedestrian-friendly, yet sidewalks occupy only a fraction of the roads.

The vast majority of smaller roads in Tokyo do not have sidewalks. These streets are narrow, which makes fast driving difficult. As a result, cars are well-behaved and people are free to walk in the middle of the road, moving over casually as vehicles approach. Here’s a typical scene from Kiyosumi, Koto-ku, Tokyo:

The benefit of narrow streets is described by the respected American blog, Strong Towns:

“Very few vehicles use local streets, and the ones that do drive slow and cautiously – similar to navigating a parking lot. Because it’s safe, there’s little need to segregate the different users of the street (pedestrians, cyclists, motorists.) If you drive, you spend most of your time on the arterial streets. If you walk, you can spend most of your time navigating the local streets in an environment that feels very natural to a human (you’re not dedicating a large chunk of it exclusively to the automobile.)”SOME THOUGHTS ON NARROW STREETS, March, 2015

Tokyo’s narrow streets were also the subject of a study, presented to the Canadian Institute of Traffic Engineer, that compares traffic data in Toronto and Tokyo. The report showed that (narrow) 10-foot lanes are safer than wider road options (while still handling the same amount of traffic for both cars and large vehicles. A 2015 article from Better Cities & Towns notes:

“Narrower lanes reduce vehicle speed, which has a big impact on fatalities in urban places. The average speed at collision in Toronto, with wider lanes, is 34 percent higher. That is likely to result in accidents of much greater severity. Although accidents appear to go up with lane widths narrower than 10 feet, these accidents are also likely to be less severe. Tokyo has a lot of streets that are narrower than those deemed “safest,” yet that city has by far the safest roads while maintaining the highest capacity.”Over-wide streets? You may regret it, Better Cities & Towns, August 7, 2015

The article includes the “curve of death”, which shows that pedestrian fatalities increase significantly when impact speed rises above 20-25 mph (32-40 km/hour).

ped-deaths-graph

Tokyo’s (generally) pedestrian-first culture can be illustrated by the ubiquitous Tobidashi とびだし / 飛び出し signs, which warn drivers of children in the area. (tobidashi means “jumping out” or “popping out”.)

A wonderful example from a Twitter user:

Tokyo’s urban streets are also described here:

Happy walking!

Advertisements

2 comments

  1. […] The term “traffic calming” refers to measures to slow or otherwise influence the behavior of drivers in order to make roads safer for other drivers, pedestrians, and cyclists. This is achieved through a variety of methods such as speed bumps (aka “sleeping policeman”) or curb extensions. In Japanese, traffic calming is translated as 交通静穏化 or phonetically from the English as トラフィック・カーミング. In Tokyo, many side streets don’t require additional traffic calming features, as the narrowness of such roads seems to be enough to keep speeds down; the perceived safety of Tokyo’s side streets is evidenced by the many people who walk near the middle of the road, moving to the side as cars approach (see previous post: Narrow streets with people walking in the road). […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.